Michael K. Allen & Associates
Call now! Available 24/7 513-823-4224

New “Making a Murderer” ruling denies coerced confession

When investigators charge someone with a crime, they are likely to interrogate the suspect. However, where does a tough interrogation cross the line into bullying to get the answer they want to hear?

An update in the famous trial from the documentary series “Making a Murderer” raises concern about how investigators should question suspects, particularly children and mentally impaired individuals.

A suspect in the case, Brenden Dassey, confessed to being an accomplice in a sexual assault and murder crime with his uncle. The judge sentenced him to jail. Dassey appealed his conviction because he claims that prosecutors forced him to give a false testimony.

Furthermore, Dassey’s lawyer asserts that he was especially prone to pressure due to his age and limited mental capacity as evident in his IQ test. His lawyer believes that the prosecutors should have been aware of this sensitivity and must always adjust their tactics accordingly.

However, the judge disagreed. He ruled that Dassey’s confession was valid because he was not under pressure when he made the confession. Several other judges wrote letters of dissent, which stated that Dassey’s lawyer was correct to say the confession wasn’t accurate.

Although Dassey may not have been under pressure in the courtroom when he confessed, the judge might not have considered what happened beforehand.

The prosecutors, simply by questioning Dassey the way they question other suspects, could have warped his own perception of the truth. This could be an example of internalized false testimony, which is when the suspect starts to believe that the accusations must be true, even if they can’t remember what really happened.

Prosecutors, judges, and attorneys all need to make special considerations for those who are mentally impaired or very young in order to prevent false testimonies. These people who may be vulnerable to coercion should seek the help of a skillful attorney in order to ensure that justice and truth prevail.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • FOX 19 / Michael K. Allen provides legal direction on-air through his appearances on FOX 19 NEWS. Visit the media section to learn more and watch our videos. / Latest Videos
  • 700 WLW / Listen to Michael K. Allen on 700 WLW Radio / Latest Podcasts

Main Office
4010 North Bend Road, Suite 200
Cincinnati, OH 45211

Phone: 513-823-4224
Fax: 513-579-8703
Map & Directions

Satellite Office
810 Sycamore Street
Cincinnati, OH 45202

Map & Directions

Review Us

Tell Us About Your Legal Issue

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy